Pride and Prejudice vs. Jane Eyre
As two of the most popular novels of all time,
Pride and Prejudice and
Jane Eyre have an incredible number of spin-off books written about them. Two of the books tipped to be summer bestsellers this year are
Eligible - a modern retelling of
Pride and Prejudice, and
Jane Steele - a modern retelling of
Jane Eyre. But do they both work in the modern era?
The Jane Austen News came across an interesting argument from Constance Grady writing for online magazine
Vox, that argues that perhaps one of them does not.
Pride and Prejudice gave us an enduring romantic comedy formula, and it’s easy to update it with only minimal tweaking here and there. You can’t do the same thing with Jane Eyre. Brontë wasn’t writing anything like a romantic comedy or a comedy of manners — she was writing a gothic romance that was also an aspirational marriage plot.
Jane Eyre never condemns the love story between Jane and Rochester, madwoman in the attic be damned. It does not function if the book does not believe wholeheartedly in the rightness of Jane and Rochester’s marriage. So when you try to turn Jane Eyre into a contemporary romance, you have to fight against either the gothic elements or the marriage plot. The results are uncomfortable.
What do you think? Can
Pride and Prejudice and Jane Eyre be translated into modern day settings? Or are the stories purely of their time?
Jane Austen News is our weekly compilation of stories about or related to Austen. Here we will feature a variety of items, including craft tutorials, reviews, news stories, articles and photos from around the world. If you’d like to include your story, please
contact us with a press release or summary, along with a link. You can also
submit unique articles for publication in our
Online Magazine.
Don’t miss our latest news –
become a Jane Austen Member and receive a digest of stories, articles and Jane Austen news every week. You will also be able to access our online Magazine with over 1000 articles, test your knowledge with our weekly quiz and get offers on our
Online Giftshop. Plus new members get an exclusive 10% off voucher to use in the Online Giftshop
